Kate arrives home early from her trip and is surprised to see Ella, the nanny, leaving her house on a day she wasn’t supposed to work. When questioned, Ella and Kate’s husband, Dan, offered shaky explanations that didn’t add up. What was the real story behind the unexpected visit? My husband, Dan, and I have been together for nearly a decade. We’re blessed with three beautiful kids: Lucy, six, Ryan, four, and our littlest, Abbie, who’s just turned one,

Dan works as a professor at a university, and I’m a wedding photographer. My job requires me to travel, sometimes even to other countries. Our nanny, Ella, has been with us for two years. My sister and some of her friends recommended Ella to us, and we never had any problem with her. The kids adore her, and she’s been fantastic. She’s also quite attractive, which I never thought was an issue until one evening that really shook me. I got back from a trip earlier than planned, and Ella was there, slipping out of our house at 10 p.m. It was her day off, so her presence struck me as odd,

“Ella, is everything okay? Did Dan need you for something?” I asked as I approached her. She turned, her eyes wide with surprise. “Oh, Kate, you’re home early! No, everything’s fine. I just left my phone inside. Silly of me, right?” I nodded, though a nagging feeling tugged at my mind. As I entered the house, I saw Dan sitting on the couch, engrossed in his phone. He saw me and smiled. “Oh, honey, you’re back early. How was your trip?” “It-It was fine,” I replied, my mind still racing with what I’d seen outside. “Dan, why was Ella here today, on her day off?”

I finally asked him. “I saw her leaving just now.” His smile faded. “Oh…uh, she wanted to lend a book. Yeah, a book,” he replied. I frowned. “A book?” It didn’t make sense. I felt like they were hiding something. But I didn’t want to look silly by accusing them without proof, and I also knew that if they were having an affair, they wouldn’t accept the truth without evidence. So the next day, with the house quiet and Dan at work, I searched his office. I felt terrible for doubting him, but I couldn’t shake the feeling something was off. There, I found a black box hidden on a shelf inside a cabinet. Nervously, I opened it. Inside were “Happy Anniversary” balloons and another smaller box. Opening that, I found two wedding rings; one was clearly for a man, thicker and simpler in design, and the other, delicate and feminine, designed to complement the first.